The famed Blue Ribbon Analysis of the 2015 Preakness is up on the horse racing page.
The Blue Ribbon Kentucky Derby Analysis is up on the Horse Racing page.
Hip #1226 was purchased today at the Keeneland Sales by Avon Barksdale. At least he has the money. Keeneland should become concerned, however, when Bub signs a ticket.
Late August in Saratoga is a special time. The temperatures are starting to moderate and the late afternoon sun bathes the race track in a special light. Thursday was not such a day. It rained all night, so that by early in the morning, the New York Racing Association postponed the steeplechase stake and took the remaining turf races off the grass. After scratches, the remaining nine races saw three five-horse fields, three with six and two with seven. With dark skies threatening more rain, it was not an auspicious day for going to the track. This is what it looked like in mid-afternoon:
NYRA announced the attendance as 18,093. This represents a 31 per cent increase over last year’s number for the same day, when it was “fast and firm” for the whole day. NYRA’s cooking-of-the-books on attendance has been written about previously, with Paul Post of The Saratogian discovering that NYRA counts some 6,000 season passes in the attendance figure, whether or not a pass holder actually comes to the track.
What is not clear is why NYRA persists in falsifying the attendance. At this point they may feel backed into a corner. But no one believes their numbers – neither the racing industry nor the fans who do show up. My theory is that NYRA is little more than an arm of the Cuomo reelection campaign. No straight talk, just happy talk.
There has been speculation in the mainstream media that Cuomo is seeking to drive up his victory margin – you know, just like Chris Christie did last year before “Bridgegate” broke. I mean he has even sued to keep Zephyr Teachout off the ballot, as if she could possibly pose a threat to $30 million in campaign funds and an incumbent who still has decent favorability numbers.
Were it not for that pesky United States Attorney hauling members of his Administration before a grand jury, everything would be rosy in Cuomoland. We’ll just have to put up with the ludicrous announced attendance figures as we await the end-of-the-meet press release breathlessly informing us what a tremendous success the meet has been. Perhaps they will explain how attendance could experience such a dramatic increase, but handle is essentially flat as David Grening has been reporting in the Daily Racing Form.
Saratoga’s first week is in the books. As with so much else that differentiates summer in Saratoga during the race meet from the rest of the world, a week is not seven days. The first week is only four days and the remaining six are six days. Here are the observations of one person:
- Quality of the racing cards is generally good: In recent years, there has been an abundance of 5 1/2 furlong turf races and low level claimers, many of which were at six furlongs. So far, we have been treated to a variety of races, including honest-to-goodness allowances. Only three claiming races of $20,000 were run, and only six turf races at 5 1/2. The fields were of good size except for the number of short fields on “giveaway Sunday,” where five of the races had fields of six or fewer. I hope that is not an indication that NYRA thinks they can get away with short fields if they are giving away what they describe as a “premier prized mementos.”
- But how much longer will these stakes retain their grade? The opening day feature has been the Grade II Schuylerville. This year’s running attracted a field of only five, forcing NYRA to make it the third race on the card to make for more attractive betting opportunities in the later multi-race exotic wagers. I read somewhere that the winning Beyer was only a 68. The CCA Oaks on Sunday was a Grade I event that attracted all of six entrants, none of whom had yet won a Grade I. The purse was $300,000, which makes the running of
TapitureUntapable in the Haskell a sensible decision given that a second-place finish there would be a larger purse than winning a race that had been a significant event for three-year old fillies.
- Is attendance up or down? It is going to be somewhat difficult to make meaningful comparisons between this year and previous ones since NYRA has decided sensibly to no longer include the “spinners” on giveaway days in the paid attendance. But the Friday, Saturday and Monday attendance was about where it was two years ago, with the average for the three days being 56 customers higher this year. Last year saw the meet open with such oppressive heat that the biggest discussion on Opening Day was whether to cancel.
- NYRA’s cosmetic changes are mostly positive: The new monitors are an improvement, and the added picnic tables in the backyard are less obtrusive than I expected. Enlarging the downstairs clubhouse restaurant removed some of the benches, but still left some in place. One negative on the picnic tables, however, is that by placing them so close to the paddock, the ability of fans to go to the paddock has been seriously restricted. On the weekend, some of those tables near the paddock were covered by tents, meaning access was even more limited.
- Who are the guys with NYRA badges who seem to have nothing to do? I spent a delightful Monday afternoon just walking around in the backyard area. I was struck by seeing several employees with the NYRA name tags who seemed to have nothing to do. I realize they may be yet more customer service representatives – in addition to those at the “May I help you” stations upon entering the track – but it was kind of puzzling. Perhaps if there was a bigger crowd they would have some work.
That Monday walking around made me realize how much we can take the Saratoga experience for granted. While going to any race track can be a venture from the real world to a different, totally contained one, Saratoga is more akin to a fantasy. It’s a beautiful facility located in the nice part of town, and features the best race meet in this country if not the world. And it is but a short walk to a vibrant downtown or a short drive to beautiful country, whether it be the farms five miles away or the start of the Adirondack mountains 30 miles from here.
Yet it is a fragile environment for racing in New York. The government-controlled NYRA is preparing a plan for the future structure of racing in New York. One news report said the draft would be ready next month, but there is no indication that NYRA will share it with either the public or the tens of thousands whose livelihood depends on the racing and breeding industries.
Then there are the signs that NYRA’s management just doesn’t get it. There is the limited access to the paddock. They stopped selling clubhouse passes after marketing them in what I thought was a great way to blunt the criticism for increasing prices this year. It is hard to believe that they are so strapped for cash that they would curtail one of the best fan-friendly initiatives they have – with the increased handle that would accompany those going more often because of the pass.
In a press release they issued after the first weekend, they actually hailed an event that show-cased an “all natural, cold-pressed, no concentrate, no sugar added juice” that you may only have seen in Thruway rest stops – I’m not making this up. This would be the same weekend in which they gave up on an ill-conceived idea to limit the availability of a beloved, free newspaper, The Saratoga Special, which has done more to promote interest in Saratoga’s racing than all of their over-the-top press releases.
We should not lose sight of the fact that this is Chris Kay’s second year at the Spa. After the fiasco the Belmont Stakes was for many fans – with no apology forthcoming – he continues to make rookie mistakes.
The Blue Ribbon Belmont Stakes Analysis is up on the Horse Racing page.
The Board of Directors of the New York Racing Association held the only meeting it is scheduled to have over a six-month period on Wednesday. The public portion of the meeting lasted all of 56 minutes. The meeting’s brevity and lack of any meaningful discussion indicates either that the real discussions are happening behind closed doors in violation of state law, or that there are no meaningful discussions. I am not sure which is worse.
It is not as though NYRA does not have significant matters on its plate. It is charged with recommending a reprivatization plan to the Legislature by April 18 next year. In addition, NYRA continues to operate a deficit in its racing operations, and must decide what, if anything, to do about the VLT revenues that enable it to operate in the black. Then there is declining attendance, even at its signature Saratoga meet, and the question of whether Aqueduct should remain open.
You would not know from attending the meeting, however, that anything is amiss. CEO Chris Kay engaged in his typical happy talk. You have to give him credit, however, for mustering enthusiasm for a Belmont Stakes music line-up that includes Frank Sinatra, Jr. and an Eagles cover band. Board Chairman David Skorton proclaimed that it was a “very positive year,” that NYRA was “closing in on a balanced budget,” and added that Belmont Stakes Day is a “perfect example of the progress we have made.”
There is no question that June 7 has the potential to be a special day of racing and handicapping with six Grade I events. But the hopefully outstanding card was achieved by eviscerating Belmont’s Memorial Day, an event that had featured the Met Mile and two other Grade I’s. This year the feature was a Grade III that lured a less-than-robust 6,946 patrons through its turnstiles.
But in terms of the “progress” claimed by Skorton, it is not clear what he means. NYRA ended the first quarter with a loss of $10.2 million from racing operations even though handle from all sources increased compared with the same three months last year. Even after including the revenues from VLT”s, the deficit was, as Chris Kay reported, “only” $1.5 million. Attendance at Aqueduct was down six per cent from last year despite three more racing days. (Yes, I know it was an unpleasant winter, but I believe the facility has heat.)
I fear that Skorton’s notion of progress has nothing to do with improvements for fans or the horsemen, but rather just the fact that they are not the old and discredited NYRA. (Many of the improvements at tracks were actually initiated by the former group.) Neither NYRA’s leaders nor other high-level state officials miss an opportunity to boast about their running racing in an open and transparent manner. The reality, however, is that NYRA does neither.
NYRA is required to follow New York laws governing access to public records and public meetings. I have detailed previously NYRA’s blatant disregard for the public records law. The NYRA Board misrepresented the financial terms of CEO Chris Kay’s contract and then attempted to cover up the distortion. This latest meeting of the Reorganization Board indicates they may be taking a similarly cavalier approach to the open meeting law.
At his first meeting as Chairman, David Skorton stated that all meetings of both the full Board and its committees would be public. The Executive Committee, chaired by Skorton, has never had an open meeting; the Finance Committee has never held one; the Long-Term Planning Committee has never held one.
The full Board does conduct a public meeting, but it is so devoid of content and serious discussion that it is legitimate to question whether it is just a sham to feign compliance with the law. If it is indeed a sham, it raises the possibility that meaningful discussions on the future of New York racing are taking place in secret.
The other possibility, of course, is that no such discussions are taking place, even behind closed doors. It was at last August’s Board meeting that Chairman Skorton stated that NYRA should start operating as if the VLT revenues are no longer there. His proposal was greeted with significant dissent, an unusual occurrence for this Board. Since then, there has been almost no mention of this crucial matter. Nor has there been an actual discussion of what is being considered for the reprivatization report that is due in a little over ten months.
The bottom line is that it is now almost two years since the Governor rammed through a somnolent Legislature, with the approval of a flaccid NYRA Board, a takeover of the organization running Saratoga, Belmont and Aqueduct. While they did a great deal of chest-thumping on how New York’s tracks would now witness substantial improvements with a competent and open leadership, I am hard-pressed to identify a single significant difference.